This decade most law-enforcement agencies adopted the patrol carbine as a supplement to or replacement of the patrol shotgun. Some agencies have re-purposed shotguns for less lethal munitions like this Mossberg Model 500:

I humbly disagree. I believe the shotgun remains the best short-range weapon available to citizens. Apparently others agree with me as there was a very strong showing of new shotguns from manufacturers at the NRA Exhibit hall. Here are the shotguns I found notable.
Remington 870 Express Tactical

Pros: Reliable design, excellent sights and rail for optics, price
Cons: Heavy, requires training
Calibers: .12 Gauge, 2 3/4″ or 3″
Price: $479.00
The Remington 870 has a strong presence in the marketplace and use among both law enforcement, military and civilians which means there are many parts and accessories available and it is proven in the field as a reliable and effective weapon.
Remington added an optics rail, ghost ring sites and an extended magazine (7 round) on the 870 tactical which just happens to be the two of the most common after-market modifications made by 870 owners when using the platform to build a personal defense shotgun. (My 870 has had an extended magazine and ghost rings for years.) Kudos to Remington for responding to their consumers.
I am not sure how civilians would find the tactical extended choke useful but you have to admit, it looks cool!

The Remington requires basic training…more than the average handgun and is heavy, particularly if held at the low-ready, on target or at at port-arms for any period of time. To address this issue, I would recommend a tactical sling for the personal defense shotgun (more on tactical slings later).
__________________________________________________________
Stoeger Double-Defense

Pros: Short, lightweight, rails for optics and lights, simple
Cons: Limited capacity 2-rounds
Calibers: .12 Gauge, 2 3/4″ or 3″
Price: ?
This shotgun system I found to be a creative mix between old and new technology. The century-old side by side shotgun design with modern optics, lights and sights seem to work with the Stoeger Double Defense.
I own a Stoeger coach gun and have found that I can go from port-arms to hits on target faster with the coach gun than with my fastest semi-auto shotgun. The problem is I have only two rounds to fire before I have to go into a reload.
Although there are no guarantees in a gun-fight, the chances are two well-placed shotgun hits will end the fight. In reality, you have to count the time it takes to retrieve, load and bring to bear the weapon not just the time it takes to fire the shotgun. A smaller, lighter, more-simple shotgun gets in the fight sooner.
In the vast majority of shotgun deployments, the weapon is brought to bear and not fired. Under these circumstances, the Stoeger Double Defense here too holds an advantage due to weight and shorter overall length than a pump or semi-auto shotgun.

The Stoeger Double Defense’s greatest advantage is its simplicity. The single-trigger, break-top design can be learned very quickly by even novice shooters and the weapon naturally points in the direction you are facing…illumination, optics and a fiber-optic front sight further improve the process of acquiring a quick sight picture. Smaller-stature shooters may want to give the Stoeger Double Defense a try in the lower-recoil 20 gauge.
___________________________________________________________
Mossberg Model 500 J.I.C.

Pros: Short, well priced for a full kit
Cons: No shoulder-stock
Calibers: .12 Gauge, 2 3/4″
Price: $422.00 – $ 547.00
I like this offering from Mossberg because they are marketing the shotgun as part of a ‘Survival Kit-In-A-Can’ and include a buoyant, portable, water-tight container…a survival knife, gun lock and swivel studs for a sling. The Mossberg 500 J.I.C. comes in matte black, desert camo and what they call ‘mariner’ which is presumably rust-resistant.
The top-mounted thumb activated safety is counter-intuitive to Remington and Benelli shooters and the more advanced Mossberg shotgun sights are absent on this platform that relies on a rear ramp/front bead for sighting. The six-round capacity magazine is generous for a compact shotgun.
I have owned and fired the Mossberg 500 in pistol-grip configuration. Although I am partial to the Remington and Benelli, I consider the Mossberg 500 with a pistol-grip a ‘good enough’ weapon. In this case I would have recommended a folding shoulder stock but like the sights, it may have made the shotgun too large for the container.
Bonus points to Mossberg for making yet another cool modification to their basic shotgun platform. These Mossberg 500 tactical mods scored points for glamor.


